joe-manchin build-back-better inflation-reduction-act climate fossil-fuels class-analysis follow-the-money
related: _Joe Manchin Master Profile · Enersystems and the Personal Coal Fortune · Koch Network - Charles Koch
donors: Fossil Fuel Bloc · Koch Network - Charles Koch
content-readiness:: developed
The BBB Kill and IRA Fossil Fuel Concessions
Money
Joe Manchin killed $186 billion in climate provisions from Build Back Better — the largest climate investment in American history — and then extracted the Mountain Valley Pipeline, mandatory fossil fuel lease sales, and weakened methane fees as the price of supporting the smaller Inflation Reduction Act. The fossil fuel industry’s total lobbying spend on BBB was $400,000+ from coal alone plus broader energy industry pressure. Manchin’s one vote delivered what hundreds of millions in lobbying might not have achieved: the systematic gutting of transformative climate legislation.
Build Back Better: What Manchin Killed
| BBB Provision Killed | Cost | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Clean Electricity Performance Program | $150B | Would have mandated utilities shift to 80% clean energy by 2030 |
| Extended clean energy tax credits | $36B+ | Accelerated renewable deployment |
| Methane fee (original version) | Revenue | First direct fee on fossil fuel emissions |
| EV incentives (original scale) | Significant | Faster transportation electrification |
| Civilian Climate Corps | $10B+ | 300,000 jobs in climate resilience |
The Timeline of Obstruction
| Date | Event | Donor Context |
|---|---|---|
| July 28, 2021 | Manchin signs private memo with Schumer proposing $1.5T cap (vs. $3.5T sought). Demands Energy Committee “sole jurisdiction” over clean energy standard; requests “innovation not elimination” of fossil fuels; demands carbon capture support. | — |
| Summer 2021 | Manchin holds “weekly meetings” with ExxonMobil lobbyists per leaked Greenpeace recordings. Exxon’s stated strategy: push natural gas within any clean standards, not block standards outright. | ExxonMobil active lobbying |
| October 15, 2021 | New York Times reports Manchin tells White House he will not support CEPP. White House begins revising bill to remove the $150B provision. | — |
| October 20, 2021 | E&E News reveals Manchin took $400,000+ from fossil fuel interests in July–October 2021 alone — while negotiating BBB. Donor list: ConocoPhillips, Energy Transfer Partners, Williams Companies, HollyFrontier, Plains All American, Enterprise Products Partners. | $400K fossil fuel surge during CEPP blockade |
| October 2021 | Manchin’s stated reason for killing CEPP: “I’m not going to sit back and let anyone accelerate whatever the market’s changes are doing.” Claims BBB would “use taxpayer dollars to pay private companies to do things they’re already doing” — both arguments disputed by energy analysts. | — |
| Late Oct–Nov 2021 | Democrats delete entire CEPP from bill to keep Manchin. Remaining climate package shrinks to ~$320B in clean energy tax credits. Manchin also opposes methane fee and EV incentives. | — |
| November 2021 | House passes revised BBB (CEPP removed) and sends to Senate. | — |
| December 19, 2021 | Manchin announces on Fox News Sunday (not to White House) that he will not support BBB at all. Stated reasons: inflation, the deficit, Omicron variant. Says legislation would “dramatically reshape our society” and make nation “more vulnerable.” Also jeopardizes black lung disease benefits for coal miners. Biden reportedly “blindsided.” | — |
| February 1, 2022 | Manchin declares BBB “dead” on Senate floor: “I am not going to vote for Build Back Better.” | — |
| Spring–June 2022 | Biden and Schumer resume negotiations with sharply scaled-back bill. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine drives up gas prices, strengthening Manchin’s “energy security” argument. | — |
| July 2022 | Manchin again walks away from negotiations — even after appearing to agree to deal. Schumer tells colleagues deal is dead. | — |
| July 27, 2022 | Manchin and Schumer surprise with Inflation Reduction Act deal — smaller bill with major fossil fuel concessions built in. | — |
Inflation Reduction Act: What Manchin Extracted
The IRA passed August 2022 with $369 billion in climate and energy investments. But Manchin’s fossil fuel concessions restructured the bill to ensure continued fossil fuel expansion alongside renewable deployment.
The Fossil Fuel Concessions — The Price of Manchin’s Vote
1. Mandatory Oil and Gas Lease Sales (Offshore)
- IRA required federal government to hold three offshore oil and gas lease sales that Biden administration had attempted to cancel
- Reinstated a fourth sale that federal court had invalidated
- By September 2023, Manchin claimed IRA had “spurred 10 oil and gas lease sales” totaling $564 million in receipts
- Manchin’s characterization (October 2023): “To address that, in the IRA we prohibited Interior from issuing wind and solar leases unless the Department also holds significant oil and gas lease sales, both on- and offshore.”
Source: Senate Energy Committee, September 22, 2023 (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED)
2. Mandatory Oil and Gas Lease Sales (Onshore)
- IRA prohibits federal wind and solar leases unless government first holds oil and gas lease sales on federal land
- BLM must offer minimum 2 million acres (or all nominated areas, whichever is lesser) before granting wind/solar rights-of-way
- Renewable energy development is structurally tethered to fossil fuel extraction
Source: Harvard EELP analysis: IRA Onshore Leasing (Tier 2)
3. Mountain Valley Pipeline (MVP) Side Deal
- 303-mile natural gas pipeline from West Virginia to Virginia
- Manchin negotiated separate side deal with Schumer and Speaker Pelosi to hold votes on permitting reform legislation before fiscal year 2022 end
- Would have:
- Fast-tracked MVP specifically
- Shortened NEPA environmental review from 6 years to 1–2 years
- Reduced lawsuit statute of limitations from 6 years to 150 days
- Blocked current MVP lawsuits
- Permitting bill ultimately failed in September 2022 when Progressive Caucus blocked it from spending resolution
- Manchin tried again to attach it to December 2022 NDAA — also failed
- MVP ultimately completed in 2024 via separate legislation
- Donors involved: Equitrans Midstream (MVP co-owner: $15,800 to Manchin 2017–2022 cycle); combined Manchin + Schumer received $340,000+ from MVP-related companies
Source: American Prospect, September 21, 2022: Permitting Reform Is a Decoy for Ramping Up Gas (Tier 2); E&E News, December 7, 2022: Manchin’s Last Gasp Permitting Effort Fails (Tier 2)
4. Expanded Carbon Capture (45Q) Tax Credit
- IRA expanded and extended 45Q tax credit for carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCS)
- Manchin specifically demanded this provision in July 2021 memo to Schumer
- Worth approximately $3 billion in credits
- Beneficiaries:
- Enterprise Products Partners ($159K donor; “game changer” per CEO)
- Coal-fired power plants (enabled Petra Nova CCS project in Texas to restart after 3-year idle; new projects at plants in New Mexico and North Dakota)
- Criticism: 500+ environmental organizations argued CCS “delays needed transition away from fossil fuels” and uses unproven technology to extend coal and gas plant lifespans
Source: Sludge: Manchin Delivered ‘Game Changer’ to His Top Donor (Tier 2)
5. Methane Emissions Fee (Weakened)
- Original BBB included $775 million methane fee rising to $1,500/metric ton by 2026
- IRA version weakened: exempts small operations, phases in gradually
- Includes $850 million in industry grants to monitor/reduce methane (effectively subsidizing compliance)
- Manchin called original version “punitive”
Source: E&E News, July 28, 2022: Manchin revives climate deal — what’s in the $369B bill (Tier 2)
6. Other Fossil Fuel Provisions
- Royalty rate increases for oil and gas on federal land (Manchin framed as “balanced” — accepted higher rates in exchange for guaranteed auctions)
- API watermark on draft: American Petroleum Institute watermark reportedly found on leaked memo of Manchin’s permitting reform draft — suggesting API effectively wrote provisions of the legislation
Source: Food & Water Watch: Manchin’s Dirty Side Deal Sidelined (Tier 2)
Contradiction
The IRA is celebrated as the largest climate investment in American history ($369 billion). But the fossil fuel concessions Manchin extracted ensure that climate investment is permanently tethered to fossil fuel expansion. The law mandates that the government sell oil and gas leases as a precondition for renewable development. The “climate bill” structurally guarantees continued fossil fuel extraction. Manchin didn’t just extract a compromise — he embedded fossil fuel dependency into the architecture of climate legislation itself.
The Fossil Fuel Donor Pipeline — Detailed Breakdown
Top Corporate Donors (2017–2022 Cycle)
| Company | Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Enterprise Products Partners | $159K | #1 corporate donor for 2022 cycle; son-in-law Marshall Roberts employed since 2020; also gave $380K lobbying Congress on BBB, CEAA, and Financing Our Energy Future Act |
| Energy Transfer Partners | $86.2K | Co-founder Kelcy Warren maxed at $5,800; hosted Trump fundraiser |
| Tellurian Inc | $45.4K | LNG company; was top 2022 donor at one point |
| ConocoPhillips | $36.9K | Also lobbied Manchin directly; CEO Keith McCoy confirmed “weekly meetings” |
| Drummond Company | $25.9K | Coal company |
| Valero Energy | $22.3K | Refiner |
| Plains All American Pipeline | $21.6K | Pipeline operator |
| Williams Companies | $19.3K | Pipeline operator |
| EQT Corporation | $18.5K | Largest U.S. natural gas producer; Appalachian focus |
| Diversified Energy Company | $18.3K | Natural gas operator |
| Equitrans Midstream | $15.8K | Spun off from EQT; Mountain Valley Pipeline co-owner |
| Domestic Energy Producers Alliance | $14.5K | Industry group |
| ExxonMobil | $10K | 2018 cycle; lobbyist Keith McCoy admitted “weekly meetings” with Manchin |
| Shell USA | Donated 2022 | — |
| Marathon Oil | Donated 2022 | — |
| Ovintiv Inc | Donated 2022 | — |
Source: OpenSecrets Contributors 2022 Cycle (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED)
Oil & Gas Executives — Q3 2021 Peak Donations (During BBB Negotiations)
| Executive | Company | Title | Amount | Timing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ryan Lance + wife Lisa | ConocoPhillips | CEO | $5,000+ each | Jul–Oct 2021 |
| Kelcy Warren + wife Amy | Energy Transfer Partners | Chairman | $5,800 (max) | Jul–Oct 2021 |
| Harold Hamm | Continental Resources | Chairman | $5,000+ | Jul–Oct 2021 |
| A.J. Teague + wife Rungnapa | Enterprise Products Partners | Co-CEO | $5,000+ | Jul–Oct 2021 |
| Jeffrey Hildebrand | Hilcorp Energy | Chairman | $5,000+ | Jul–Oct 2021 |
| Richard Kinder | Kinder Morgan | Executive Chairman | Donated | Jul–Oct 2021 |
| Trevor Rees-Jones | Chief Oil and Gas | Founder | Donated | Jul–Oct 2021 |
Summary: $400,000+ from fossil fuel interests in single quarter while Manchin blocked CEPP.
Source: E&E News, October 20, 2021: Manchin has raked in $400K in fossil fuel donations (Tier 2)
Company PACs — Q3 2021 Maximum Donations
All six of these PACs donated exactly $5,000 (legal maximum) in the same quarter:
- ConocoPhillips PAC — $5,000
- Energy Transfer Partners PAC — $5,000
- HollyFrontier Corp PAC — $5,000
- Williams Companies PAC — $5,000
- Plains All American GP LLC PAC — $5,000
- Enterprise Products Partners PAC — $5,000
Total coordinated PAC donations: $30,000 in single quarter
Source: E&E News, October 20, 2021 (Tier 2)
Electric Utility Companies (CEPP Opponents)
| Company | Amount (2017–2022) | Career Total | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| NextEra Energy | $49.6K | Largest U.S. utility company | |
| Dominion Energy | $23.6K | Appalachian Power parent; Manchin’s 2nd-largest Senate utility donor after Schumer (Chuck Schumer got more) | |
| DTE Energy | $15K | — | |
| PG&E Corporation | $17.8K | — | |
| Exelon | Donated Q3 2021 | — |
Career utility donations: Over Manchin’s entire Senate career, utilities gave roughly $647,452 — his 7th largest donor industry overall.
2022 status: Manchin ranked #2 Senate recipient of utility money (behind Chuck Schumer) for 2022 cycle. All utilities opposed CEPP because it would have penalized them for slow decarbonization.
Source: OpenSecrets Contributors 2022 (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED); Gizmodo, October 2021: The Dirty Utilities Funding Manchin’s Bullshit (Tier 2)
Coal Company Historical Donors (2010–2012)
| Company | 2010 Cycle Industry Total | 2011–2012 Cycle Industry Total |
|---|---|---|
| CONSOL Energy | — | $3,940,000 |
| Peabody Energy | — | $3,860,000 |
| Alpha Natural Resources | $608,000 | $2,646,395 |
| Arch Coal | $1,910,000 | $1,810,000 |
| Murray Energy | $559,000 | — |
Manchin’s status: Designated #1 coal mining industry recipient in the Senate in both 2010 and 2012 cycles.
Source: OpenSecrets Coal Mining Summary 2010 (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED); OpenSecrets Coal Mining Summary 2012 (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED)
Beyond direct contributions, the fossil fuel industry’s influence on Manchin operated through multiple channels: industry association lobbying, direct executive access, coordinated PAC campaigns, and the structural reality that West Virginia’s economy depends on fossil fuels. But the unique Manchin factor is personal: unlike other fossil fuel-funded senators, Manchin’s own income ($500K+/year from Enersystems) directly depends on coal continuing to burn.
Energy Committee Chairmanship: Structural Amplification of Fossil Fuel Influence
Manchin became a member of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee when he entered the Senate in November 2010. After Democrats took the Senate majority in 2020, he became chairman — a position that gave him extraordinary power over energy legislation, oversight, nominations, and hearings.
Committee jurisdiction includes:
- Federal oil, gas, and coal leasing on public lands
- Nuclear energy and waste policy
- Energy efficiency and renewable energy programs
- Department of Energy oversight and programs
- Global climate change (oversight authority)
- Pipeline regulation (in coordination with FERC)
Structural amplification: As both (a) the 50th Democratic vote in a 50-50 Senate (maximum legislative leverage) AND (b) the chairman of the Senate’s primary energy jurisdiction committee (maximum regulatory leverage), Manchin had uniquely elevated positions from which fossil fuel donations could purchase maximum influence.
OpenSecrets designated Manchin #1 Senate recipient (2021–2022) from:
- Oil & Gas industry
- Natural Gas Transmission & Distribution industry
- Coal Mining industry
- Tobacco industry
- Mining industry
Key power moves:
- October 2021: Used committee leverage to demand “sole jurisdiction” over any clean energy standard, which effectively gave him veto power over BBB’s centerpiece climate provision (CEPP)
- March 2022: Blocked Interior Department nominee Laura Daniel-Davis (assistant secretary for lands and mineral management) using committee chairmanship to freeze her vote until Biden clarified federal oil & gas leasing plans
- March 2022: Only Democrat to join Republicans in voting to overturn EPA heavy-duty truck emissions regulation
- May 2023: Vowed to oppose every Biden EPA nominee in anticipation of proposed EPA rules on coal and natural gas power plant emissions
- FY2023–2024: Inserted report language into funding bills directing DOE to give “full and fair consideration” to fossil fuel projects and not “discriminate” against coal or natural gas power plants
- February 2023: Convened Energy Committee hearing on coal technology where he personally pushed DOE to invest in “gob” waste coal — the exact fuel his own Enersystems company burns, earning him $500K+/year
- July 2024: Co-authored Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024 with Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY) requiring minimum federal oil/gas/coal lease sales; extended oil and gas drill permits; fast-tracked offshore gas under FAST-41; set coal leasing deadlines. Passed committee but never reached full Senate.
Enterprise Products Partners leverage: Manchin’s largest corporate donor ($159K in 2017–2022 cycle) also gave $369,700 to members of the Senate Energy Committee in 2022 — using the committee as an investment vehicle.
Source: Senate Energy Committee 2023 Year in Review (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED)
Sources
- Congressional Budget Office: Estimated Budgetary Effects of HR 5376, Inflation Reduction Act (Tier 1)
- OpenSecrets: Manchin industry and contributor data (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED)
- E&E News: Manchin has raked in $400K in fossil fuel donations (Tier 2)
- E&E News: Manchin revives climate deal - what’s in the $369B bill (Tier 2)
- E&E News: Manchin pushes DOE to invest in coal that earned him millions (Tier 2)
- Washington Post: Manchin’s opposition to BBB undercuts Biden’s climate agenda (Tier 2) (UNVERIFIED)
- New York Times: Biden’s clean energy plan faces a test (Tier 2) (UNVERIFIED)
- Politico: Manchin proposed $1.5T topline number to Schumer this summer (Tier 2) (UNVERIFIED)
- NPR: Manchin says BBB climate measures are risky. That’s not true. (Tier 2)
- American Prospect: Permitting Reform Is a Decoy for Ramping Up Gas (Tier 2)
- Food & Water Watch: Manchin’s Dirty Side Deal Sidelined (Tier 2)
- Grist: IRA promises new oil leases (Tier 2)
- Harvard EELP: IRA Onshore Leasing Provisions (Tier 2)
- Senate Energy Committee: Manchin on IRA fossil fuel production (Tier 1) (UNVERIFIED)
- Sludge: Manchin Delivered ‘Game Changer’ to His Top Donor (Tier 2)
- Jacobin: Joe Manchin is a very good friend to fossil fuel donors (Tier 2)
- New Republic: Joe Manchin is a Very Good Friend to His Fossil Fuel Donors (Tier 2)